In the so called Internet society, access to all kind of information is available to all or almost all, at least in western economies. A simple search on the web allows us to enjoy eyes-cutting materials on a specific field of knowledge. Should you be interested on marketing, for instance, out there you will find the best speakers and gurus able to illuminate your path via YouTube, twitter, blogs, etc. TED talks are perhaps a very good example of how to enjoy the latest and most innovative findings on different fields from all over the world.
Innovative and astonishing talks, they are. The strong communication skills often exhibited by the invited speakers leave one with the impression of having attended his/her long life conference. I have recently noticed an increasing attention on this from my students. Many of them comment to me directly. I also bet that many of those who sit in the bottom with computers are sometimes watching this kind of materials. I try to be comprehensive in that point. It is not easy for a regular professor tops such speakers. Needless to say that they are far more striking than reading and digesting the large volumes from one´s university library. So why should one go to college? This question has lately been swirling around in my head and I wanted to pose in class, with excellent results, by the way.
The truth is that one could stay at home watching online talks on the Internet, reading the best blogs and following the most influents thinkers of one´s specific discipline. Imagine you do that for as many years as a regular university degree lasts. Five hours a day from Monday to Friday. Would the results be the same? Would your personal development be the same? It seems difficult to answer such question positively. This is it because attending class is more than the above arguments. Here are the top eight reasons why you should attend class:
- To have a “paper”. Without beat around the bush, attending class is likely to be one of the requirements to obtain the desirable title of graduate. It is actually an essential for many professors. In other words, it will conduct you to obtain a paper that proof that you have indeed attended university. There is somehow a materialistic reason, after all.
- To acquire social skills. But it is not a materialist reason what makes attending class important. Taking part of discussions, the fact of stating your opinion, disagree or agree with your classmates, working in teams or paired off and listening other´s opinions are an essential part of any class session. Although it is true that this point strongly depend on how the classes are conducted by the professor.
- To acquire social capital. Gaining a paper proving that you are economist or sociologist or whatever may be important to getting a job after graduating. However, it is no longer a guarantee of that. What might be, on the other hand, is the so called social capital, i.e. the amount of people you know that may in the future be part of you network or even your future employer, as well as the quality of such social relations. Do not discard to cooperate with many of your class mates in the future. The fact of having experienced together the same period of live in the university it is sometimes the top reason to start up new projects. This is something unachievable when watching YouTube videos. Not even the more and more common online university programs can equalize the power of physical university in that sense.
- To acquire cultural capital. Strictly connected with social capital it is the so called cultural capital. The term was first introduced by the well know French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu and refers to non-financial social assets. Examples can include education, the “university spirit”, intellect and style of speech, dress, body language or physical appearance. Attending university is more than acquiring new knowledge. It is a crucial period of life that shapes our identity as persons. Something that will distinguish you from other people and even from other faculties. It is well know the cultural difference between those who attend humanistic and technical degrees. All this things, in a long term, may make the difference in; for instance, promote yourself beyond economic means. In other words, your future employers may hire you not just thanks to your paper, but due to the fact that your way of behavior proof that indeed, you have attended university. This is especially true if we assume the increasing facility to obtain a “paper” nowadays. More and more non-conventional university degrees are proliferating all over the world. In two words, in occasions is just your bank account what separates you from having the “paper”. But this is not a guarantee of learning.
- To have a routine. The globalization has brought us major flexibility to our everyday life. At contrary to our parents’ generation, working hours are no longer shared by the majority of the people in the same city. Night shifts, half time contracts, weekend university programs, etc. make it possible. Having an everyday routine may be something truly difficult. You may be excited about that idea. Should you like living differently every week, this life style may be your ideal. However, it is not clear that the lack of routine is always desirable. What is more, it can make you less productive since you sometimes cannot even predict your working hours the next week. Hence you cannot do things in advance. You cannot have your own plan. Attending class every day allows you to better organize your own life. Not only your class hours but also your sport time, social life, commuting, etc. This point brings up another important affair that I hope to address in the future: the convenience of attending university during the weekend. Such advantages as having a half time jobs appears. But to what extend one is not missing many of the advantages of everyday interaction, as mention above, social capital, social skills, etc.?
- To be closely evaluated. New and moderns university formats, as online programs, have frankly improve in the way professors and students interact. Thouthough evaluations of students are also possible thanks to online platforms and chatting software. Skype is probably the best example. However, the distance between students and professors as well as among students makes the difference. It is especially true if we assume that the word evaluation is more than just grading students, but also remarking and commenting arguments and taking part of activities in class. As one of the students said in class, we all are mirrors of one another. Observing others is the best way to assess you.
- Because “the medium is the message”. This phrase, coined by Marshall McLuhan (1987), expresses very well the importance of class attendance. It means that the form of a medium embeds itself in the message, creating a symbolic relationship which the medium influences how the message is perceived. In that context, the universe around university is still a dominant medium in comparison to others. Even if the messages are apparently less revealing than, for instance, TED Talks, they will likely have more effect on you as person and professional.
- Because “too much information is nowadays worse than ignorance”. This idea, suggested by the well-known polish sociologist Zygmunt Bauman tells us that nowadays accessing information is not a guarantee of wisdom. It was in the past, when knowledge was reserved to elites. But now, in the so called internet society, it does not make the difference anymore. At most you will be a “jack of all trades”. So what does now make the difference? Accessing the right knowledge. University programs are, somehow, a selection of the most relevant knowledge in a specific field. Everything cover in classes are somehow part of a whole designed by specialist in a given matter.
Are you perhaps thinking of more reasons? Let us know your opinion.
Marshal, McLuhan (1987). Understanding Media: The Extension of Man. Ark, London.
Bourdieu, P. (1998). The state nobility: elite schools in the field of power. Stanford University Press.
I’m all about the research when it comes to talking about education. I really appreciate this post. Thanks. I’ll be back.
You will be always welcomed!
University has lost its emancipatory capacity.http://www.sinpermiso.info/textos/nuestro-sistema-universitario-ha-perdido-su-capacidad-emancipatoria-entrevista